lisa helene donovan bacalski

Home » Editor's Note » Assumptions and Presumptions (My Letter to Dear Abby)

Assumptions and Presumptions (My Letter to Dear Abby)

Dear Abby,

I’ve read your column for years. Though I don’t always agree with you, I think your insights are valuable because you often help letter writers see their problem from another perspective or at the very least laugh. I often find your comments insightful and enlightening. Unfortunately, your January 6th answer to GENUINELY PUZZLED was truly upsetting.

The letter writer was confused about why a poor young couple with a baby and a toddler who were asking for help near a shopping center would refuse her offer of groceries and request cash instead. Your response assumed that the beggars were frauds who borrowed the children in order to raise more money. It may have been necessary to alert the writer to the reality of professional panhandlers, but it would have been more helpful to also include a charitable alternate view of their situation. Given our current economy, it is not fair to assume that every young family on the streets is there by choice and “doing quite well,” as you wrote.

I have been in Genuinely Puzzled’s situation, and I think she would have appreciated actual advice about how to really help families on the street instead of your professional blow-off. You mentioned that “Some families are truly in need and should be guided to a shelter so they can receive help getting back on their feet.” That is vague pabulum; you failed to suggest any real action that your letter writer (and readers) can take to prepare themselves by contacting local churches and community service organizations to find out what shelters and services exist in their area. Many groups have information cards and service coupons that can be given out instead of cash. Directly supporting such programs through financial support, advocacy and volunteering not only helps people escape homelessness, it can also be rewarding and eye-opening.

This couple said they wanted money to choose their own food and pay their phone bill. It’s their prerogative not to accept a gift that would have been more of a burden than the giver intended. From my conversations with people who are homeless or living in their cars, I have learned that groceries like fresh meat and pasta sauces are useless if you do not have a stove or refrigerator. They either spoil or become one more thing that must be carried. Canned soups like the letter writer mentioned are nutritious but heavy. Daily life in poverty, whether on the streets or in a shelter, is an obstacle course of conflicting rules, laws, schedules and expectations that even college students in a ‘guided experience of homelessness’ find difficult to bear. Your response made it sound as though living on the streets was a career choice, and I will admit that it provoked some rather uncharitable thoughts about you, your career and your privileged background. Then the picture below popped into my Facebook feed and made me think again:

YouCAT-tiff

A single advice column can not cure every social ill, and that is not your purpose or your job. Yet it is a shame that instead of educating your readers, you reinforced negative stereotypes that ultimately make it more difficult to provide help to people who have been made poor by circumstances not always within their control. I hope you will avoid this mistake in future columns.

Advertisements

4 Comments

  1. Susan scott says:

    I did not see the original Abby letter LisaHelene but I am much impressed by yours. Measured, calm, informative. It is possible that couple with babe may be chancers. Here in South Africa women carry babies on their backs and beg and it is a known fact that many times they are borrowed babies.
    Anyway, may your letter to Abby help others to think more about this and to find out where they can guide those on the streets to find shelter.

    • lisahelene says:

      I fixed the link to the letter so you can read it if you’re interested, Susan. Professional beggars and chancers are a problem that complicates helping people living on the streets and the public needs to be educated about it. The general response may be that the couple in the letter should be in a shelter but very few people realize that here in the US most areas do not have enough space in the shelters, especially for families with children. That’s why I was so upset that Abby didn’t encourage her readers to support worthy organizations.

  2. Jessica says:

    That was a rather quick response with not much thought by Dear Abby! Quite disappointing. Great follow-up letter! I enjoyed your thoughtfulness and insight…more people should learn not to be so fast to assume things.

  3. Very nice post. I appreciate your compassionate yet practical perspective.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: